Friday, 20 November 2026Cataluña 20°/ 12°

Breaking

Vox and PP clash over Catalan identity and its place in Spain

Vox argues that Catalan identity is dual and part of Spanish identity, while PP rejects it as a concession to nationalism after the debate in October.

Jordi Cubarsi
Jordi Cubarsi
· 2 min read

Vox defends that Catalan identity is dual and part of Spanish identity, while Cayetana Álvarez de Toledo from the PP rejects it as a concession to nationalism. The clash exposes two distinct ways of understanding Spain.

The debate over Catalan identity has opened a new disagreement between Vox and PP, the two right-wing parties furthest from independence and aspiring to govern after the 29N elections. According to La Razón, the clash reveals two ways of understanding the fit of Catalonia within the country as a whole.

The leader of Vox, Santiago Abascal, expressed his position on October 25 in an interview with La Vanguardia. He argues that Catalan identity is not exclusive, but dual and part of Spanish identity, and that both must be protected against what he attributes to mass immigration. Abascal places the threat in Islamism, above the model of the State.

From Vox, they clarify that each territory, such as Andalusia, Madrid, Canary Islands, or Asturias, has its own traditions, an idea that several social media users have commented on.

“I think it’s a grave mistake, I see it as part of the Catalan nationalist discourse.”

The response came this Wednesday from Cayetana Álvarez de Toledo, leader of the PP, who said she was “very” surprised by Abascal’s “astonishing turn.” She rejects attributing a collective identity to Catalans and argues that each person has their own. For her, contesting the nationalist vote does not require adopting the language or premise of a Catalan identity that needs protection.

The disagreement reflects two readings of the relationship between Catalonia and Spain. Vox acknowledges a shared Catalan identity but integrates it into a broader Spanish identity. Álvarez de Toledo is wary of assigning collective identities to a territory and places the issue on an individual level.

The reference text also distinguishes two other historical traditions. One is the traditionalist and Catholic thought, with Carlism as a reference, which defended the fueros and autonomy of the territories under a common monarchy, more present in Catalonia, the Basque Country, and Navarra. The other is the centralising liberal tradition of the 19th century, which promoted a more uniform territorial organisation from Madrid. The analysis warns that neither of these traditions exactly coincides with the current positions of the parties.

Jordi Cubarsi

Written by

Jordi Cubarsi